57 million smokers and vaping enthusiasts reached since 2015!
September 25, 2017

Texas Man Claims Vaping Gave Him Popcorn Lung

A Texas man is claiming that vaping has caused what he claims is popcorn lung. But the story doesn’t add up.

Tommy Lowrance, a business professor at a Waco community college, told KCEN-TV that he has been diagnosed with popcorn lung after vaping for “a short period of time” to help him quit smoking.

He said that soon after he quit smoking with e-cigs, “I was healthier than I’ve ever been.” Then the 45-year-old says he was diagnosed with popcorn lung.

“I can’t exhale air out of my lungs at all,” Lowrance told the NBC affiliate. “I have about a 20-percent lung function. For most Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) patients, say, they have far better lung function than me.”

What is popcorn lung?

Popcorn lung is a slang name for a condition called bronchiolitis obliterans (BO). It gets its name from a group of workers in microwave popcorn factories that were stricken with BO after breathing large quantities of flavorings.

Popcorn lung is caused when the smallest airways within the lungs (bronchioles) are scarred, and their capacity and efficiency are reduced to the point that breathing becomes difficult. There is no cure for BO except a lung transplant.

BO is impossible to accurately diagnose without doing a surgical lung biopsy — which requires opening the chest — and sometimes not even then. And the symptoms are easily confused with those of COPD, a far more common condition. COPD is common among longtime smokers.

Further, the chemical that is usually blamed for BO — the flavoring component diacetyl — is found in much higher concentrations in cigarettes than it is in e-liquid. In fact, e-liquid that contains high levels of diacetyl is very uncommon these days.

Despite the fact that diacetyl is far most evident in cigarettes than e-liquid, no smoker has ever been diagnosed with BO. And no vaper has been either.

Where is the evidence?

The TV station asked few questions of Mr. Lowrance, essentially accepting his story at face value. And we were unable to find any other accounts of his medical ordeal. The KCEN article claims that Lowrance has “been treated by some of the best lung doctors in the world,” but none of the doctors were quoted in the article.

The story says that, “although they cannot say definitively that his condition came as a result of vaping — simply because there is not enough information available yet about long-term effects — they all agree it was most likely the cause.”

That’s disturbing. If some of the best lung doctors in the world “all agree” that vaping is “most likely” the cause — based on guessing — why weren’t they quoted in the article? If this is all true, reporter Chris Rogers might earn a Pulitzer Prize for exposing a real danger of vaping. This would become a recognized hazard, rather than just a fantasy of fact-averse anti-vaping activists and a dream of personal injury lawyers.

Who profits from the fear of popcorn lung?

who-profits-popcorn-lung

It’s not surprising that the fear-mongering articles like this one have created an atmosphere ripe for exploitation by personal injury lawyers. Searching “popcorn lung Texas” on Google, I found attorneys among the most popular links.

Even if a link cannot be proven between vaping and popcorn lung, a lawyer can be successful merely by threatening vape manufacturers. Businesses with liability insurance may find their insurance companies would rather settle for a portion of what the suit seeks than to dedicate the effort and expense required to fight the accusation in court.

Every time a story like this surfaces, a few more smokers decide to steer clear of vaping and stick with their cigarettes. The reporters never explain that even if the story is true, cigarettes are still much more dangerous than vaping.

But the story is not true. The story is never true. And the result is that more smokers will get sick and die.

Smokers created vaping without any help from the tobacco industry or anti-smoking crusaders, and vapers have the right to keep innovating to help themselves. My goal is to provide clear, honest information about the challenges vaping faces from lawmakers, regulators, and brokers of disinformation. I recently joined the CASAA board, but my opinions aren’t necessarily CASAA’s, and vice versa. You can find me on Twitter @whycherrywhy
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
9 Comments
most voted
newest oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Chris Anderson
Chris Anderson
3 years ago

So if I claim that 35 years of smoking has given me popcorn lung will it receive the same kind of media attention that this fuckwits laughable story has got?

Tara Caron Antonuccio
Tara Caron Antonuccio
3 years ago

I thought the only way to diagnose popcorn lung was through an autopsy. Am I misinformed?

KillingTime
KillingTime
3 years ago

Many years ago, I worked for a pharmacy delivering replacement oxygen cylinders to patients suffering from COPD. Many of them had a hard time speaking, having to take big, wheezing breaths between each word. And yet Mr Lowrance claims to have lower lung function than most COPD patients, while having no apparent difficulty speaking at all.

The stench of BS is strong with this one.

WeAreAllMadHere
WeAreAllMadHere
3 years ago

I had pneumonia many years ago and my lung capacity was down to 25%, talking is almost impossible over very short sentences. Eating was problematic, so was drinking anything. Walking was a long process to move any distance. My O2 sats were around 89% on 3 l/m. This guy is talking and moving around way to good to be at 20% lung capacity.
I wonder why he thinks his COPD is not from smoking? A better question, why don’t his doctors?

WeAreAllMadHere
WeAreAllMadHere
3 years ago
Reply to  Jim McDonald

It used to be true that if you could not verify sources, then it was not a story.
One of the problems with a 24 hour news cycle is that it appears people just make stuff up and others believe without verification.
I remember the three channel days, of course I didn’t care about news then.

Best Beginner Vapes in 2021
LEARN MORE
Vaping360
FOLLOW US
© Vaping360, All Rights Reserved.