Advertisement
Advertise with us
sidenav

Deeming Rule Challenge Rejected by Federal Appeals Court

Advertisement
Advertise with us

A federal appeals court today upheld a lower court's rejection of a challenge to the FDA Deeming Rule brought by several small vaping businesses. The case, Moose Jooce, et al v. Food and Drug Administration, had previously failed in a federal district court in February.

A three-judge panel of the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia upheld the earlier decision by U.S. District Court Judge Christopher Cooper. The appellants (plaintiffs in an appeal) can now request a rehearing by the full Circuit Court, or apply to appeal the case to the Supreme Court.

The lawsuit, which consolidated three separate complaints brought by small vaping businesses and Minnesota-based non-profit group Tobacco Harm Reduction 4 Life, challenged the FDA Deeming Rule on Appointments Clause and First Amendment grounds. The legal action was bankrolled and argued before the courts by the Pacific Legal Foundation, a conservative-libertarian public interest law group that fights government overreach.

The vape industry plaintiffs had claimed that because the Deeming Rule wasn’t signed by a government officer appointed by the President and approved by the Senate, that it violated the Appointments Clause of the Constitution. Like many federal regulations, the Deeming Rule was signed by a career civil servant, in this case Associate FDA Commissioner Leslie Kux.

Quote

The appellants (plaintiffs in an appeal) can now request a rehearing by the full Circuit Court, or apply to appeal the case to the Supreme Court.

But Circuit Court Judge Judith W. Rogers, writing for the panel, said that because the Deeming Rule was later ratified by then-FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb in 2019, any defect in the regulation was cured. The panel rejected all arguments against Gottlieb’s after-the-fact endorsement of the rule.

The vapor industry appellants had also challenged the Deeming Rule on First Amendment grounds, asserting that claims by vape shop employees about the relative safety of vaping cannot be preemptively censored by speech limitations imposed by the FDA's "modified risk" approval requirements.

In the original decision, Judge Cooper said that he was bound by precedent set by the 2019 U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision in the Nicopure Labs LLC vs FDA appeal. In that case, the appeals court agreed with the original 2017 district court decision, in which Judge Amy Berman Jackson found that the FDA's speech restrictions on the vaping industry were appropriate.

Today, Judge Rogers also said the argument was “foreclosed” to the appellants, meaning that precedent set in the Nicopure Labs decision prevented further consideration of the First Amendment claim.

The three appeals court judges were appointed by three different Presidents: Judge Rogers by Bill Clinton, Judge David B. Sentelle by Ronald Reagan, and Judge Cornelia T.L. Pillard by Barack Obama.

Vaping360 reported in September on oral arguments before the circuit court.

Advertisement
Advertise with us
Latest Reviews
Article preview image
Freemax REXA PRO & REXA SMART Review: Too Smart?

The Freemax REXA PRO and REXA SMART are highly advanced pod vapes, offering seemingly endless features, beautiful touchscreens, and new DUOMAX pods.

Wed Jul 30 2025
Article preview image
OXVA XLIM Pro 2 DNA Review: A Match Made in Heaven!

The OXVA XLIM Pro 2 DNA is powered by a custom-made Evolv DNA chipset, offering a Replay function and dry hit protection. Read our review to find out more.

Fri Jul 18 2025
Article preview image
SKE Bar Review: A Reusable Crystal Bar!

The SKE Bar is a 2 mL replaceable pod vape with a 500 mAh battery, a 1.2-ohm mesh coil, and 35 flavors to choose from in 2% nicotine.

Mon Jul 7 2025
Advertisement
Advertise with us
Latest Learn
vaping taxes
Vaping Taxes in the United States and Around the World

Because of declining cigarette sales, state governments in the U.S. and countries around the world are looking to vapor products as a new source of tax revenue.

Thu Jul 31 2025
How Old Do You Have to Be to Vape?
How Old Do You Have to Be to Vape?

The legal age to buy e-cigarettes and other vaping products varies around the world. The United States recently changed the legal minimum sales age to 21.

Tue Jul 1 2025
Where vaping is banned or restricted
Vape Bans: E-Cigarette Restrictions in the U.S. and Worldwide

A list of vaping product flavor bans and online sales bans in the United States, and sales and possession bans in other countries.

Fri Jul 4 2025
About Authors
Jim McDonald
843 posts

Smokers created vaping for themselves without help from the tobacco industry or anti-tobacco crusaders, and I believe vapers and the vaping industry have the right to continue innovating to give everyone who wants to use nicotine access to safe and attractive non-combustible options. My goal is to provide clear, honest information about vaping and the challenges nicotine consumers face from lawmakers, regulators, and brokers of disinformation. You can find me on Twitter @whycherrywhy

See author’s profile
Vaping360.com strives to be the world's most trusted resource for vapers and smokers. We take pride in our editorial integrity, accuracy, and the honesty of our writers.
Read more about us

Rely on Our Expertise

At Vaping360, we take pride in our deep expertise and years of experience in the vaping industry. Our dedicated team of professionals is committed to leveraging their extensive knowledge to meet your needs and exceed your expectations.

Authenticity

Genuine insights backed by thorough and exhaustive research and testing.

Reliability

Consistent, accurate information from the vaping industry experts.

Empowerment

Transparent and reliable content for confident and informed decision-making.

About us

Our mission is clear: to help people who smoke transition to low-risk alternatives and contribute to a smoke-free world. With each article we publish and each review we conduct, we're working towards this goal.

about-us-banner
product preview